|
||||||||
T H E F R E N C H C E N T R E F O R R E S E A R C H
A N D S T U D I E S O N T H E W O R L D E C O N O M Y The CEPII - Past CEPII Newsletters - PDF Format - Subscribe / Unsubscribe C O N T E N T S: FOCUS Economic
Implications of International Migration Flows
While the globalization process has come with the rapid liberalization of trade and capital flows, restrictive migration policies have expanded during the last decades. However, international migration has really begun to slow down after the triggering of the global economic crisis. Immigrants are indeed directly exposed to the effects of the recession, being the first affected by the rise of unemployment, notably in the construction sector. As a result, remittances to developing countries have declined over the last year, hence increasing the vulnerability of emigration nations already hit by the drop in exports and foreign capital inflows. Against this background, and despite the lack of employment opportunities and the strengthening of border controls in industrialized countries, there have been more and more incentives to emigrate. But beyond the current crisis, what are the long-term implications of migration movements? Recent research at the CEPII tries to answer this question by focusing on three main thrusts: the economic impact of immigration, the brain drain between knowledge based economies, and the link between remittances and financial development. The economic and political debate about the impact of migration is highly controversial. Recent contributions, however, show that owing to their complementarity with native people in terms of age and education, immigrants do not have any detrimental impact on income or productivity of host countries. In the long run, unskilled immigrants even seem to have a positive impact on host country productivity by affecting its total factor productivity and raising the equilibrium investment rate in the economy. Furthermore, the fact that leading OECD countries have a declining labor force while they concentrate the largest part of the world capital suggests two adjustment mechanisms: either capital moves to where workers are, or workers move to where the capital is. Thus, a low labor force with an abundant capital generates conditions for high earnings which attract workers from low earnings regions. Allowing the migration flows to be related to economic fundamentals (using INGENUE 2, a multi-region overlapping-generations general equilibrium model) induces important changes in the volume and the distribution of the migration flows between regions compared to United-Nations projections. Nevertheless, despite their size, these flows will not be sufficient to offset the effect of ageing, leaving room for pension reforms. As for immigration countries, the adverse economic consequences appear to be all the more important that the region is advanced in the ageing process (and is already suffering from a declining population). Another line of research puts the emphasis on the brain drain between knowledge based economies. Indeed, since 1990, European emigrants to the United States are increasingly selected from the upper tail quality distribution of their source country workforce in terms of education, scientific knowledge, and unobservable skills. As a matter of fact, these cohorts include a larger proportion of engineers, researchers and academics than the previous ones. The nineties surge has been amplified by the fact that returnees were fewer, older, and relatively less educated. Preliminary evidence shows that the brain drain reflects the weakness of demand for skilled labor in Europe. Besides, technological changes triggered by human capital losses could make these outflows increasingly costly for Europe in terms of productivity, and could affect the innovation activities targeted by the Lisbon Strategy. Finally, research at the CEPII focuses on the role of workers’ remittances in the development of emerging markets, namely pre-1914 peripheral European countries. Remittances, which tend to be less volatile than other capital flows, helped to reduce the incidence of financial disturbances – sudden stops and current account reversals – in receiving countries, in particular among those integrated in the gold standard. Remittances also contributed to the development of European countries’ financial sector. Given that financial development is regularly included among the conditions for economic growth and catch up of developing nations, such result adds to the understanding of the multiple impacts of international migration on the economies of emigration countries. They also suggest that public authorities in today’s developing countries should try to maximize the impact of remittances by adopting policies aiming to promote financial democracy. References: Ethnic Networks, Information, and International Trade: Revisiting the Evidence
Deregulation
and technological progress have decreased trade costs. There are many
empirical studies dedicated to the analysis of the importance of these
changes. In particular, studies of the border effect have shown that informal
barriers are still important (Rauch and Trindade, 2002 – henceforth R&T).
Recent empirical works show that migration contributes to decrease informal
trade barriers between countries and thus enhances their bilateral trade.
The overall contribution of this study is to revisit the findings of R&T. More precisely, we extend the literature in two main ways. First, we propose a theory-grounded gravity framework for the estimation of the network effects. This allows to discuss the identification of the trade-cost channel of networks. We argue that, excluding the links of ethnic minorities with the ethnic majority country, one may minimize the preference effect and come closer to the pure trade cost effect. Besides the identification issue, we use state-of-the-art econometric techniques to the data of R&T. We show that the large trade-creating effect of 60% estimated by R&T is probably two to four times too large. Most of the overestimation comes from the omission of the multilateral resistance terms; the preference channel seems to be less important. The second part of our contribution is to extend the analysis beyond the Chinese network studied by R&T. Using data from the World Bank for the year of 2000, we proxy the networks of some ethnic group k by the stock of individuals born in k but residing in some foreign country i or j. This gives us a more narrow definition of ethnic networks than the one used by R&T, because it excludes descendants of individuals who have migrated long ago or whose parents have always lived as ethnic minorities in those foreign countries. Moreover, the World Bank data allow to check for the existence of other ethnic (or better: migrant) networks. Besides the Chinese network, we document the existence of a Turkish, a Mexican, or a Pakistani network, to name only a few. Interestingly, in terms of trade-creating potential, the Chinese network is by far not the most important one. We also find substantial heterogeneity in the trade-creating potential of different networks which we can partly explain by characteristics of the migrants’ countries of origin. For example, when the share of high skilled individuals in the source country is larger, or the population less strongly ethnically fragmented, the network effects are smaller. Gabriel J. Felbermayr, Benjamin Jung & Farid Toubal
How do Different Exporters React to Exchange Rate Changes? Theory, Empiric and Aggregate Implications This
research analyzes the reaction of exporters to exchange rate changes.
We present a model where, in the presence of distribution costs in the
export market, high and low productivity firms react differently to a
depreciation.
Whereas high productivity firms optimally raise their markup rather than the volume they export, low productivity firms choose the opposite strategy. Hence, pricing to market is both endogenous and heterogeneous. This heterogeneity has important consequences for the aggregate impact of exchange rate movements. The presence of fixed costs to export means that only high productivity firms can export, firms which precisely react to an exchange rate depreciation by increasing their export price rather than their sales. We show that this selection effect can explain the weak impact of exchange rate movements on aggregate export volumes. We then test the main predictions of the model on a very rich French firm level data set with destination-specific export values and volumes on the period 1995-2005. Our results confirm that high performance firms react to a depreciation by increasing their export price rather than their export volume. The reverse is true for low productivity exporters. Pricing to market by exporters is also more pervasive in sectors and destination countries with higher distribution costs. Consistent with our theoretical framework, we show that the probability of firms to enter the export market following a depreciation increases. The extensive margin response to exchange rate changes is modest at the aggregate level because firms that enter, following a depreciation, are smaller relative to existing firms. Nicolas Berman, Philippe Martin & Thierry Mayer
Spillovers from Multinationals to Heterogeneous Domestic Firms: Evidence from Hungary It
is widely believed that multinational firms increase competition, transfer
technology and help to achieve more efficient allocation of resources.
Inward Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is often seen as a catalyst for
development by many governments because it increases domestic firms’ productivity
by creating linkages between multinational and domestic firms. This explains
various programs that Governments in Central and Eastern European countries
have launched to attract FDI in the early nineties.
Firms cluster their economic activities to exploit technological and informational spillovers from other firms. Spillovers from multinational firms can be particularly beneficial to domestic firms especially in less developed economies, because technological superiority and management experience of foreign multinational firms should theoretically yield various opportunities for learning. The empirical literature on FDI spillovers finds however mixed support concerning the impact of spillovers on domestic firms’ total factor productivity (TFP). Certainly, firms react to foreign presence in a rather heterogeneous manner. According to a recent survey conducted by the World Bank among Czech and Latvian firms, 23 per cent of firms state that the presence of multinational firms enhances their knowledge about new technologies, 13 per cent state the enhancement of their marketing know-how. However, about 29 per cent of the domestic respondents consider inward FDI to be responsible for their loss of market share. We expect a similar pattern for Hungarian firms. Some domestic firms can reap spillovers from multinationals, but others may not. We argue that the impact multinationals have on domestic firms depends on (i) the intensity of the linkage, (ii) domestic firms’ absorptive capacity and (iii) their ability to face competition. The competitive pressure from multinational firms could be the starting point for a positive development if it raises process and product innovations (Aghion et al., 2005). It could turn out to be negative for domestic firms if they just lose their market share. The liberalization process in Hungary could have increased competition, pushing some domestic firms to exit the market and others to innovate. Our aim is to analyze the different responses of heterogeneous domestic firms to the expansion spread of multinational firm presence in Hungary. Gábor Békés, Jörn Kleinert & Farid Toubal
Consumption Tax, Wage Tax and Monetary Policy Facing
the ongoing ageing process, European countries will have to address a
significant increase in the cost of their social system. The large public
debt inherited from the 2008-2009 economic crisis adds to the demographic
burden. Taxes mainly rely on consumption or labor. However, taxing either
consumption or labor is not neutral and tax incidence has a broad literature
already.
Departing from this point of view, we focus on the short term impact of shifting taxation rate, due to imperfect price adjustment and the monetary policy. First, we assess the monetary policy problem in the presence of tax shocks (consumption and labor tax rates) in a stylized closed economy model. This model embodies the fact that firms differ in their pricing behavior after a VAT tax increase: some of them pass it through consumption price immediately; others smooth the price increase over several quarters. Optimal monetary policy depends on the relative share of each behaviour. A Taylor rule is able to reproduce fairly the optimal policy, provided that it takes into account the convenient share of producer (excluding tax) and consumer (including tax) prices. We estimate the share of the two kind of firms using the 3 percentage points German's January 2007 VAT increase as a natural experiment. We use disaggregated consumer price data for Euro area 12 countries in order to disentangle the sector specific price dynamic from the effect of the tax shock. A two country DSGE model calibrated for Germany and the rest of the Euro area shows that the short term impact of a tax increase on inflation and the output-gap is different depending on the modified tax (consumption tax, workers' contributions, firms' contributions) and the schedule of pre-announcement. We then estimate the macroeconomic impact on Germany and the rest of the Euro area of the policy effectively implemented on January 2007: the output loss due to the tax reform reached 0.1% of GDP in the rest of Euro area: a national tax shifting from labor to consumption weighs on the rest of the currency union. Institutional
Profiles Database 2009 (IPD 2009)
The
Institutional Profiles Database (IPD) project aims at providing researchers
with a quantitative evaluation of a wide set of institutional characteristics
at the country level. IPD covers 123 countries, including developed,
developing and in -transition- countries, encompassing 99% of global GDP
and 96% of the world population. The database is oriented towards the
analysis of the relationship between institutions and long-term economic
growth. IPD 2009 comes after two previous releases, in 2001 and 2006.
The next update is planned for 2012.
The complete database and the document presenting concepts and methodology(1) are freely available at: http://www.cepii.fr/ProfilsInstitutionnelsDatabase.htm
and http://www.maastrichtuniversity.nl/governance The Institutional Profiles Database was built using a survey conducted by researchers from the French Ministry for the Economy, Industry and Employment (MINEIE) and the Agence Française de Développement (AFD) in the countries covered. The purpose of the IPD project is to contribute to the measurement and analysis of the role of institutions in development. The Institutional Profiles project is organized as part of a multi-year AFD research program on “Institutions, Governance and Long Term Growth” which aims at deepening research on the role of institutions in development processes. The University of Maastricht / Maastricht Graduate School of Governance (MGSoG) is the main partner in this research program. Since 2008, the World Bank Institute has used part of IPD for producing the Worldwide Governance Indicators (WGI)(2). The average weight of IPD in the WGI is 7.2% out of 33 different sources. From a broad definition of institutions inspired by Douglas North(3) (institutions are constituted by a set of formal and informal rules that govern the behaviour of individuals and organisations), and trough a de facto approach, IPD offers a field of institutional characteristics which goes beyond governance indicators. IPD is broken down according to nine functions which are crossed on four sectors. The institutional arena is summarised in the following table: IPD's Structural Framework Nicolas Meisel & Jacques Ould Aoudia
(1) De Crombrugghe D., K. Farla, N. Meisel, Ch. de Neubourg, J. Ould Aoudia and A. Szirmai (2009): “Institutional Profiles Database III: Presentation of the IPD 2009”.
The Crisis: Policy Lessons and Policy Challenges Agnès Bénassy-Quéré, Benoît Coeuré, Pierre Jacquet & Jean Pisani-Ferry Commerce et flux financiers internationaux : MIRAGE-D André Lemelin Oil Prices, Geography and Endogenous Regionalism: Too Much Ado About (Almost) Nothing Daniel Mirza & Habib Zitouna EU15 Trade with Emerging Economies and Rentier States: Leveraging Geography Guillaume Gaulier, Françoise Lemoine & Deniz Ünal Market Potential and Development Immigration, Income and Productivity of Host Countries: a Channel Accounting Approach Mariya Aleksynska & Ahmed Tritah A Picture of Tariff Protection Across the World in 2004 MAcMap-HS6, Version 2 Houssein Boumellassa, David Laborde Debucquet & Cristina Mitaritonna Spatial Price Discrimination in International Markets Julien Martin Is Russia Sick with the Dutch Disease? Victoria Dobrynskaya & Edouard Turkish Economies d'agglomération à l'exportation et difficulté d'accès aux marchés Pamina Koenig, Florian Mayneris & Sandra Poncet Local Export Spillovers in France Pamina Koenig, Florian Mayneris & Sandra Poncet Currency Misalignments and Growth: a New Look Using Nonlinear Panel Data Methods Sophie Béreau, Antonia Lopez Villavicencio & Valérie Mignon Trade Impact of European Measures on GMOs Condemned by the WTO Panel Anne-Célia Disdier & Lionel Fontagné Economic Crisis and Global Supply Chains Agnès Bénassy-Quéré, Yvan Decreux, Lionel Fontagné & David Khoudour-Castéras CEPII Working Papers are available free, on-line, in PDF format.
ECONOMIE INTERNATIONALE, QUARTERLY Vietnam's WTO Accession and Export-Led Growth
Jean-Pierre Cling, Mireille Razafindrakoto & François Roubaud Vietnam's Accession to the WTO: Expost Evaluation in a Dynamic Perspective Houssein Boumellassa & Hugo Valin The Distributive Impact of Vietnam's Accession to the WTO Full text Jean-Pierre Cling, Mohamed Ali Marouani, Mireille Razafindrakoto, Anne-Sophie Robilliard & François Roubaud Exports Liberalization and Specialization in Cash Crop: Gains for Vietnamese Households? Barbara Coello Vietnam's Export-Led Growth Model and Competition with China Jean-Raphaël Chaponnière & Jean-Pierre Cling
Andre Varella Mollick Volatility Dynamics of the UK Business Cycle: a Multivariate Asymmetric Garch Approach Kin-Yip Ho, Albert K. Tsui & Zhaoyong Zhang Foreign Direct Investment and Economic Growth in Mauritius: Evidence from Bounds Test Cointegration Myriam Blin & Bazoumana Ouattara Trade Openess and Wage Inequality Between Skilled and Unskilled Workers in Tunisia Monia Ghazali Select your Committee: the Impact of Central Bankers Background on Inflation Etienne Farvaque, Hakim Hammadou & Piotr Stanek
LA LETTRE DU CEPII,
MONTHLY
Crisis and Trade: Bad Times for High Quality
N° 293, 23 October 2009 Similar products are imported at different prices, suggesting that varieties are vertically differentiated between low and high quality. This differentiation of varieties according to their quality enables to provide new evidence regarding the collapse of world trade during the recent crisis. The decrease of world demand has affected the imports of high quality varieties to a larger extent, leading to a decrease of import prices. Our econometric estimations over a period of ten years confirm that the revenue elasticity of import quantity is larger for high quality imports. Hence, a decrease of world revenue is expected to decrease more the world imports of high quality as compared with the imports of low quality. To the contrary, recovery should benefit more to the imports of high quality.
The G20 is not Just a G7 with Extra Chairs
N° 292, 21 September 2009 In the wake of the global crisis the G20 has largely substituted the G7 as the key forum for international economic cooperation. However, G7 and non-G7 members of the G20 come to G20 meetings with different priorities. Developed countries have taken a direct hit on their financial systems as a result of the crisis and they accordingly give priority to strengthening financial supervision. Emerging economies have been primarily affected by the collapse of trade and (mostly in emerging Europe) the outflow of capital. Their priority is thus to ward off the reemergence of protectionism. As newcomers, the emerging countries are also focused on the distribution of power in international institutions. So far, the G20 agenda has been dominated by the global turmoil and the rebuilding of financial regulation – a rather G7-like agenda. Meanwhile, it has been silent on the issue of global imbalances, where it could have made a difference. In the future, the G20’s agenda will have to evolve and better reflect the variety of concerns of its members. Agnès Bénassy-Quéré, Rajiv Kumar & Jean Pisani-Ferry
Agglomeration of Exporters Encourages Exports
N° 290, 14 September 2009 The French public administration has adopted numerous provisions intended to promote collective export campaigns and the exchange of experience between businesses in close geographical proximity. This extends from exporters’ clubs to the policies of competitiveness clusters, and the underlying idea is that strength in numbers helps to overcome the costs and difficulties involved in exporting. In two studies recently carried out on data from French businesses, we measured the impact of the geographical agglomeration of exporting firms on the efforts of firms in the vicinity to launch an export activity. This impact is heightened where the businesses in question export the same product to the same country and where the market to be won is difficult to access. These effects, which pertain to firms’ environments, are however of secondary importance compared with the characteristics of the firms themselves. Pamina Koenig, Florian Mayneris & Sandra Poncet
The Dollar - Unsafe Haven
N° 289, 29 July 2009 Just like any market price, the exchange rate for the dollar fluctuates based on supply and demand. By observing the constituent elements of the supply and demand for dollar assets, we can thus explain the significant appreciation of the dollar during the second half of 2008. Over this period, during which the crisis spread to the whole of the global economy, US Treasury bonds acted as a safe haven, but in net terms foreign investors ceased buying US private securities. Americans, on the other hand, repatriated capital on a massive scale, driving up the net demand for dollars. Supply of dollar assets fell more rapidly than the global supply of assets and thus shored up the US currency. The dollar’s future movements remain one of the greatest uncertainties following the crisis, even though the forecast made before the beginning of the crisis remains valid: if the ongoing US deficit is to be resorbed, a weak dollar will continue to be required. Will Western European Banks Pull Out of Central and Eastern Europe?
N° 288, 3 June 2009 The current financial turmoil raises concerns about supportiveness of foreign banks from Western European countries for their Central and Eastern European subsidiaries. Foreign bank presence dominates banking business in almost all countries in the region, which would make their withdrawal very painful, if not catastrophic. For Austrian and Swedish banks, this region was a source of large profits in the last years, and, therefore, they are expected to stay in the region. While recognizing individual strengths and weaknesses of each country, such strong interconnectedness calls for a region wide approach for helping ailing banks. The Emerging Countries in the International Trade of the EU
N° 287, 12 May 2009 Over the past ten years, the emerging economies, being exporters of manufactured goods, and rentier states, being exporters of commodities, have eroded the dominant position of developed countries in the world market; for the latter, they have also represented opportunities for growth and been partners in the international division of labour. As the EU15 has a fair share in these dynamic markets, its global exports have only slightly receded. Such an achievement, which was mainly made in neighbouring markets, is put at risk by the economic downturn which is affecting European emerging countries and rentier states in particular. |
||||||||
| The contents of this issue were finalised December 8, 2009 | ||||||||
|
||||||||